Eye for an Eye
By Connor McCloud



It was hard to tell who might pass out first after drinking all day. It was
the first time that my wife Beth and I had seen our high school friends in
about 10 years, and we had been laughing all day about our fun times. I had
married Beth, and our close friends, Andy and Ellen, also highschool
sweethearts, had also gotten married. We stayed close for a few years and then
with work, kids, and other things we still talked, but had not seen each
other. I invited our friends to the beach house we had rented and they had
decided to come up for the weekend.

We spent most of the day on the beach, getting some sun and having adult
beverages. We played frisbie and catch with various balls, the usual beach
stuff, while also playing with the kids, basic beach stuff. I noticed that
Ellen, always a great athlete, looked tighter and more muscular than before,
and we commented on it which made her happy. She was very proud of her figure,
and gave us all a double bicep pose on the beach and we all laughed. She
looked so good that I had a hard time not staring, and I'm sure she caught me,
but she just smiled and winked, we were old friends. Towards the end of the
day, Andy tried to toss Ellen in the ocean, but to our delight, and surprise,
it was Andy who wound up in the water while Ellen laughed and flexed her
muscles.

That night after putting the kids to bed, we sat down, and played some cards,
until basically Beth and Andy were falling asleep at the table. Andy had
brought the senior yearbook and we laughed at ourselves and how dorky we all
were. We laughed at our senior formal pictures, and Andy's blackeye that could
not be hidden with any makeup. Andy had banged his eye the day before the
formal, and we all laughed when he showed up with a large, dark shiner.

Beth and Andy eventually went to bed, and Ellen and I decided to have one more
drink. The yearbook was opened to senior formal pictures and Ellen started
laughing as I did looking at Andy's blackeye.

"You want to hear a secret Johnny?" she asked laughing with me.

"Sure sweety, let's hear it" I replied.

"You know how Andy told everyone that he fell and got his blackeye that way?"
Ellen asked moving forward towards me.

"Yeah, I remember" I responded.

"Well, that's not what really happened" Ellen said.

"Ahhh, good dirt! Let's hear the real version" I said happily.

"Well, the night before, Andy and I were together, and I found out through
some friends, that Andy was drunk, as usual, and at some party, and was
hitting on everything in sight. So we were playing around, you know how Andy
and I wrestle around together, and I confronted him with it. He denied it,
then accused me of the same stuff, and things actually became a little heated.
Technically, it wasn't a fist fight, but it was close, and to make a long
story short I kicked his ass until he admitted what he had done," Ellen said
calmly.

"What? You're saying that you gave Andy that nice Shiner! You're kidding!" I
replied laughing.

"No, I'm serious Johnny. I know you don't know this because Andy would never
admit it, but I always won our wrestling matches, and made him submit all the
time. That night he went to far and took a swing at me, so I decked him!" she
said confidently.

"No, I never did no that. Andy's a tough kid Ellen, he won his share of fights
growing up, and you were kicking his ass all the time? You serious?" I asked.

"Yeah, I'm serious. Having a hard time believing a girl can take a guy in a
fight Johnny? Andy and I use to wrestle all the time, just for fun, and you
won by submission, he won sometimes, but I won at least 75% of the time, maybe
more. I'll tell you something else, he never wins now, I'm to strong for him,"
Ellen stated with a proud look on her face," that's why Andy bought me all
that nice stuff during highschool, we bet sometimes and the winner would get a
gift. You don't believe me do you Johnny?"

"Well, I guess I do, it's just hard to believe. I mean Ellen you look great,
you really do, strong as a bull. I just never..." I stopped as Ellen placed
her arm up on the table, challenging me to arm wrestle.

"Get your hand up there Johnny, let's see how strong you are," she said
smiling.

I laughed and we locked hands immediately. What followed was the most intense
arm wrestling match I have ever had. For a long time, our hands didn't move,
which I couldn't believe. I pushed as hard as I could, but couldn't move her
an inch. Ellen, always a master of psychological warfare, never stopped
staring at me. Her muscles bulged and dance as she continued to add pressure.
I looked up into her eyes, and she was smiling at me, and we both knew she was
going to win. Ellen slowly began to move move my hand, and as hard as I
pushed, she slowly drove my hand towards the table top. Moments later she
pinned my hand, holding it there to put an exclamation point on her victory. I
was in total disbelief, and just stared at Ellen, who winked at me and rubbed
my hand softly.

"You're a strong guy Johnny, stronger than Andy anyways, that was close hun,"
she said smiling.

"Jesus Christ Ellen! I can't believe how strong you are, I mean you look
strong, but you're even stronger than you look! I never thought you were going
to win!" I said.

"Why? Because I'm a girl? Don't be a jerk J, woman are tougher than you think.
You don't think Beth is tough? She is, very tough, if she worked out more, she
would be beating your ass!" Ellen laughed.

"Listen you brat, just because you beat me in arm wrestling doesn't mean you
or Beth would be beating my ass!" I stated confidently.

"Really? You think you could take me Johnny? Want a shot at the title?" she
asked smiling.

"Here? What if someone wakes up? You think Beth would get mad or Andy?" I
asked.

"Nahh, Andy wouldn't, and Beth would love to see my making you submit, she's
into that stuff you know, we used to chat about it. We even wrestled a few
times, she tougher and stronger than you think Johnny! What do you say? I'm up
for it," she said leaning back in her chair.

"What! You and Beth used to wrestle together?! I would have paid money to
watch that! Who won?" I asked excitedly.

"We each won our share, I won more often though, but she was viscious when she
won. That Beth can be mean as a snake, almost had me in tears once she got so
into the match. One time we wrestled so hard and intense we were naked by the
time we ended, and Beth forced me to lick her nipples before she released me.
What do you think of that?" she said smiling.

"You're fucking with me now Ellen. I'll buy that maybe you guys arm wrestled,
and maybe, maybe you wrestled around after drinking all night, but wrestle
naked? Licking Beth's nipples? You're fucking with me now," I said laughing.

"Am I? Let's ask her, go wake her up, she'll tell you," Ellen said.

"I think I'll do that, she will love to hear this," I said and walked down the
hall to get Beth.

We returned moments later and Beth sat down next to me, and across the table
from Ellen.

"Hey sweety sorry to wake you, but we need to settle something," Isaid.

"That's alright sweets, what's up?" Beth asked.

"Ellen was telling me that you guys use to wrestle?" I said.

"Yeah," she said laughing, "we did a bunch of times. It was fun, great
exercise, and Ellen and I loved to compete together. That was just after high
school right Ellen?"

"Yup, high school, college time, Johnny didn't believe me, wanted it from the
horses mouth. I told him about your dominatrix side," Ellen said smiling.

"Well I don't know about that but I am very competitive. I made Ellen lick my
nipple once," Beth said laughing," because I could I guess. It was a little
over the edge, but it seemed like the right thing to do at the time. Plus, she
licked them nicely! How did this come up?"

"I told Johnny about Andy's black eye, and that lead into arm wrestling, which
of course I won, the yada, yada, yada, here we are," Ellen laughed.

"I see, lost to Ellen in arm wrestling hun? She's real strong, you should have
asked to take her on left hand, she can be beat there! At least I use to beat
her more lefty. You look lost hun," Beth said looking at me.

"I'm just confused. This is new to me, you never told me about wrestling with
Ellen, or nipple licking, or any of that! I almost agreed on wrestling Ellen
before coming to get you" I stammered.

"Really! That would be great," Beth exclaimed," I would love to watch that.
I'll root you on Honey, but my money would be on Ellen quite honestly, she's
tough."

"You serious? You think she could take me? When I was really trying?" I said
with some anger in my voice.

"Oh like you let me beat you in arm wrestling," said Ellen," I won fair and
square. Then looks like we have a match!"

Beth and Ellen excitedly jumped up and began moving furniture out of the way,
clearing a spot for our match. Ellen, took her t-shirt off, leaving her in her
bikini top, and then looking over to Beth for approval took off her shorts,
leaving her clothed in her very skimpy bikini.

"I like feeling skin on skin Johnny, take off your shirt, and wrestle in your
bathing suit," she said with authority. Beth nodded her approval so I did, and
stood in front of Ellen in the middle of the room. Ellen was around 5'6" and
looked like she weighed about 130, but now seeing her almost nude, and
noticing that she was all muscle, she might have weighed more like 145. Her
brown hair was pulled back in a pony tail, revealing well defined shoulders,
and great traps. She was more muscular than I remember her being, or even
noticed today, especially her arms which were fairly big and well formed. I
was about 5'8" and these days I was weighing around 165, and but I looked
skinny compared to Ellen, who was clearly more muscular, and well built. One
of the most notable differences in our bodies was our legs, mine were skinny,
while Ellen's legs were lean, but heavily muscled.

"Well now, this looks like a even match, although Ellen makes you look rahter
scrawny dear," Beth laughed," so I could be the ref, and you could win by
shoulder pin, but I'm fond of making your opponent submit, what do you guys
say?"

"I say submission," said Ellen right away," I'm dying to make Johnny say
uncle!"

"Whatever Ellen, we'll see, you'll be kissing my nipple before we are
through," I laughed.

"Really? We'll see about that J my friend," laughed Ellen.

The match started with Ellen and I kneeling and facing each other. Beth sat on
the couch and settled in nicely with a drink to watch the action. We came
together and the match began. At first we pushed and pulled each other testing
the others strength and balance, and right away, it was clear to me that Ellen
was the stronger person. We toppled to the floor together, rolling back and
forth, and fighting for position, and I was able to put Ellen in a side head
lock. I tightened my grip, and really dug my arm in and added pressure. Ellen,
wrapped her legs around mine, and began pulling me into her, so although I had
head her, she was slowly moving her legs so they were almost around my
midsection. Ellen now rolled us over, so she was flat on her back, with me on
top of her, and then with her hands, she forced my fingers apart breaking my
hold. Ellen was now under me, and she quickly wrapped her legs around my
stomach, and then put me in a bear hug, while rolling on her side. She
squeezed tightly with her legs digging them in tighter, and causing me
discomfort and she also began adding pressure to my chest with her arms. I
began feeling discomfort in my stomach from her squeezing, which was not here
and there, but a continuous squeeze, which only got tighter. I managed to work
her hands apart, and then tried my best to not let her put me in a choke hold
of head lock from behind which she was now trying to do. Ellen began playing
with me and taunting me knowing shew was winning, and while she did this she
began working her legs higher, so that eventually, they were wrapped around my
right arm and neck. My right arm was useless, and there was not much I could
do with my left arm. Her legs were so strong they held me motionless although
I tried to roll and rock my way out of the hold. Ellen, seeing my futile
attempts began laughing, and made herself comfortable by propping her head up
on a pillow and lying down as she squeezed tighter and tighter.

"No way out of this hun," I heard Beth say," you're done. Might as well admit
defeat and ask for another match."

"She's right Johnny, I could squeeze hard enough to make you pass out, but we
don't need that do we? Just submit and I'll let you go."

I submitted immediately and Ellen uncoiled her legs from around me. I felt
relieved from having that pressure gone, but then felt worse after realizing
that Ellen had just beat me, and beat me very easily.

"You want a rematch Johnny or are you done? You can do better than that can't
you?" Beth asked me, mocking my effort.

"Give me a break Beth alright," I snapped,"just sit there and have your
drink."

"Sounds like a challenge to me!" said Ellen," maybe Johnny needs for you to
beat him, because I know he can't beat me can you Johnny?"

I didn't say anything and Ellen came at my quickly, knocking me on my back,
and pinning my arms above my head. I struggled the best I could, but I
couldn't move, she had me pinned on my back in a perfect shoolboy pin.

"I want to hera you say in Johnny," she demanded," can you beat me?"

"No, I can't," I said quietly.

"Very good, and tell me why you can't beat me," she ordered.

"Because you're stronger than me," I said quietly.

"I'm tougher too, but that's another story," Ellen laughed," hey Beth come
over here and take off my top would you sweety."

Beth walked over and removed Ellen's top, revealing her beautiful breasts
which she lowered before me.

"Lick them Johnny, Beth won't mind, it's like tradition when you humiliate
someone like I just humiliated you, you pussy. Do it," she ordered.

I hesitated a second, but Ellen squeezed my wrists hard, and moments later I
was licking the sweat off her nipples. Ellen then dropped down quickly and
rubbed her breasts hard into my face, cutting off my air, and forcing me to
flail around on the floor. I could hear Beth laughing in the background. Ellen
stood up over me, looked down and then walked and sat on the couch. I stood up
angry and moved towards Ellen, but Beth now stood before me in a challenging
pose.

"Easy Johnny, you don't want to push this, Ellen will kick your ass, and you
know it, why not try taking your frustrations out on me," Beth said suddenly
removing all her clothes," Ellen left this out, but I prefer to wrestle naked.
It's very erotic with so much skin touching."

"What? I'm not.." I said, until suddenly interupted by Beth quickly pulling my
shorts off, leaving me standing there naked, with my erection now showing.

"Look at you all excited Johnny," said Beth softly," would it excite you more
if I told you that when Ellen and I wrestled naked sometimes we would bring
each other to orgasms. I remember one time, Ellen had me in a hold like she
had you before, but she was behind me with her naked chest against my lower
back, and while she squeezed my head so tightly I thought I would pass out,
she began fingering me. It was so good hun, I must have had four orgasms, then
I submitted, and we made love together. I'm not gay sweety, you know that, we
just were both so turned on by the physical contact, and by how intense we
were struggling and competing, it just happened, and our wrestling turned more
into intense fucking, very intense. Don't you think Ell?"

"Yeah, personally, it was one of the best sexual experiences of my life, your
wife is awesome in the sack Johnny. She gave me so many orgasms I just lost
count, and she's right it was very intense. We stopped doing it years ago,
because we both enjoyed so much we didn't think we could stop," Ellen
responded.

"Don't get me wrong John you're good in bed," Beth continued," but it's nice
being manhandled and dominated sometimes, and quite frankly, you're not strong
enough to manhandle me, but Ellen is. Her and I struggled together to see who
could make the other orgasm first it was wild, I miss that."

With all the emotions now running through my head, I lost control and tackled
my naked wife to the ground. We struggled together, my adrenaline and emotions
giving me the upper hand, and forcing her to the ground, where I began to wrap
myself around her and squueze. Beth, who is almost identical to Ellen in
stature, although leaner than Ellen, but quicker and more limber, began to
fight back harder. Beth worked her way out of my grasp, and to my dismay,
quickly went on the attack, driving her shoulder into my stomach and knocking
me back. We struugled intensly on the floor, rolling and grabbing each other,
which my wife and I had never done before. As hard as I was fighting, I began
to tire, and Beth continued her attack, and began to take control of the
match. Beth grabbed my left wrist and forced my left arm behind my back, then
she pushed me face first to the floor. Using my arm now as a lever, she moved
behind me, and sat me up. Beth without letting my arm loose, moved in behind
me, and wrapped her legs around my stomach, now sitting down behind me. She
then quickly wrapped her right arm around my neck and pulled me into her,
grinding her hold even tighter. I tried with my right arm to break her hold,
but she was to strong, and eventually, with my left arm trapped between our
bodies, she advanced her hold with her left hand. Beth now used both arms to
tighten her hold, where eventually all she had to do was flex her biceps to
force me to almost pass out. With her body coiled tightly against mine, Beth
held me in place, and toyed with me, using her legs to crush me, and her arms
to keep me there helpless as her prisoner.

"Hey Ell, how's this? Not bad for being rusty huh!" Beth laughed.

"Nicely done sweety, he never had a chance. Look at him now helpless as a
baby. You could hold him there forever, make him do or say anything, he's at
your will," Ellen replied.

"How true dear, let's see what he would say first. Hey hun, who is now in
charge of our marriage and will now make all decisions?" Beth asked.

"You are," I mumbled, gasping for air.

"Alright, and who would win in a fight, me or you dear?" Beth asked laughing
at me.

"You would," I almost cried.

"Very good, I know it's hard to learn like this sweety, but it was time I
think. Hey Ell come over here would you," Beth asked, "take off your bikini
bottoms and come closer to us sweety."

Ellen slowly removed her bikini bottom and crawled towards us like a lion on
the prowl. I was sitting with my legs open, and she closed them together and
straddled my legs kneeling in front of me.

"Alright Ell my dear, come closer to us, Johnny will service you and you and I
can kiss and play with each other. Oh yeah Johnny, lick Ellen sweety, and do
it nice, or I'll let her kick your ass, seriously, and we'll say you got
mugged or something," Beth ordered.

Ellen moved into us, pressing her vagina into my face, and using my face to
get herself off. I looked up and saw Ellen and Beth kissing pasionately, Ellen
stroking Beth's hair and touching her face softly. They held me like this for
several minutes, while Ellen continued to rub her vagina into my face and
bring herself to orgasm, almost ignoring what I was doing. Eventually they
stopped, and Ellen backed away, leaving me breathless and used like a dildo.
Beth never released me, and now she tightened her hold.

"Ellen and I are done with you, so I'll let you go. In a way I'm sorry about
this hun, but you'll get over it I'm sure. Just remember what happened, think
about it, and it will help you put it into perspective," Beth explained.

Beth released me, and I sank to the floor like jello. Beth stood up and Ellen
gave her a high five and then kissed her hard on the mouth. They hugged each
other and began to walk towards the bedroom area. I got up and with anger,
almost hatred pushing me I ran towards them. Beth whirled around, and without
hesitation, punched me square in the eye, knocking me to the ground. She stood
over me, and looked down at me angrily.

"Don't be an idiot hun, what's done is done. It's 1 in the morning, Ellen and
I are going to make love together like old times, you sleep on the couch for a
while, I'll come get you before morning. Ellen and I want some good sex
tonight, you know with a strong, dominating person, that leaves you out.
Later!" exclaimed my wife as she walked away hand in hand with Ellen.

Hours later, Beth came out and motioned for me to follow her into bed. I had
been sitting there on the couch for the entire time, to upset to sleep. The
next morning came, and I still had little sleep, maybe a few hours. I walked
into the bathroom and grabbed my toothbrush when I noticed my right eye was
swollen and black and blue. I walked out into the kithcen and everyone was
there having breakfeast and having coffee. Andy looked at me and laughed.

"Hey brother, what the hell happened to you?"

"I fell and hit my eye late last night when I was drunk, hurt like hell," I
said unconvincingly.

"Yeah, I've been there my friend, must have hurt like hell," Andy said looking
over at his smiling wife.